Name: JRH
City/State/Country: Montreal, Canada
IP Address: 70.81.198.36

Comments

Can we really stand up to China? The answer is NO. It's a case of David versus Goliath. China is a world power with a mighty military to back it. It will be better or practical if our govt diplomatically arrange a deal or a compromise to resolve this sensitive issue. As compared to other Asian countries our military is poorly equipped led by corrupt officials..be it on land, air, or sea. Any naive claim that we are capable of defending or offsetting a confrontation is pure myth. China is a giant in the world as compared to the Phils, a struggling country in Asia. So, let's just make a deal with the Mandarins & forget this notion that we are capable of defending our territory.

Name: Carlos Perez
City/State/Country: Yati,Lilo-an, Cebu
IP Address: 122.52.117.16

Comments

Pleased advise the President that our government must buy new fighter jets as our first line of defense for external or internal aggression for the security of our Country or if we can't buy now at least we must have rockets, interceptors, and other equipment such as high-tech radar that can detect intruders in our country, we must stand strong in our claimed territory such as Scarborough shoal we must construct a small pier for our Navy ships. Otherwise our marine endangered species will all be gone. Yes I believe U.S.A. will help our country but before they arrive we are already conquered. That's why we must be prepared to modernized our Armed Forces; land, sea & specially air. Thank you & more power.

Name: kali
City/State/Country: Hawaii
IP Address: 66.91.35.33

Comments

In the news; “Philippine Navy warship retreat from Scarborough shoal as demanded by China” PNoy retreating from Scarborough shoal is a shame. If PNoy can’t kick out the Chinese from the shoal, I think he should resign as President. Whatever PNoy’s excuse is not acceptable? It’s like someone invades your home and tells you to get lost. Most likely you would say “over my dead body”. International agreement of 200 mile Exclusive Economic Zone set by UN and China was one of the signatories, but now they are reneging. With China defying this agreement, Philippines should go to the UN for resolution. If UN doesn’t move, methinks the best course is fire a few salvos at the Chinese vessel and tell UN, you have the rules now impose it!

Name: HMS
City/State/Country: New York
IP Address: 67.241.96.149

Comments

Are you kidding? Let's expand the question. The way things are in the Philippines can it win anything at all? What was it that those politicians were saying when they turned the Americans away? Nationalism. Sovereignty. Danger of Nuclear attack. Then the Tans and the Sys and the GoKongweis took over the economy. Truth to tell it does not have to be China to give the Philippines some problems. Any country in the region can do that and there's nothing the Philippines can do. And to look to America now for help and assistance is just about the most pathetic thing the Philippines can do. What goes around comes around I'd say.

Name: Manuel C. Diaz
City/State/Country: Antipolo City
IP Address: 180.191.213.12

Comments

Can the Islas de Ladrones aka Philippines stand up against China? Let us do the math according to the latest census there are 92million Indios called Filipinos. There are more than one billion Chinese. If the Indios called Filipino will go to war and kill Chinese at the rate of one million Chinese casualty per day in one year you kill 360million Chinese may naiwan pang 640million Chinese. If the Chinese will also do the same favor of killing one million Indios aka Filipino per day, in 92days they wipe out the Pinoy population that is three months and 2 days.

Name: tonyo
City/State/Country: pinas
IP Address: 111.68.59.100

Comments

I agree with Atty. Harry Roque. The Philippine Government should file a case against China for the current Scarborough Shoals incident for violation of its right under the United Nations Convention on Laws of The Sea (UNCLOS) aka Treaty on Law of the Sea to which China is a signatory since it does not honor and respect its commitment to the 200 nautical miles doctrine on EXCLUSIVE ECONOMIC ZONE of the member states. Scarborough shoals is within the 200 nautical miles EEZ of the Philippines. Chinese fishing boats plundered these shoals with marine products and the Chinese Navy intimidated the PH Coastguards when these poachers were threatened with arrest. These sanamagan, sanamabits will keep on violating Pinas’ sovereignty if Pinas is meek and allows these kawalanghiyaan ng mga insects.

Name: Jorge Villanueva
City/State/Country: Canada
IP Address: 142.162.176.155

Comments

I don't want to belabor the point but I have been saying all the time that we were a highly respected country in Asia in the 50's. Economically the country was doing well and the dollar exchange was P2 to $1 a far cry from today's value. What caused the downfall ? Massive graft and corruption in all levels of nation's activity and politics became a way of life. Other countries that experienced worse situations than the Philippines recovered because of discipline and determination to succeed. We can do the same but we need to go after the grafters and corruptors of the nation's wealth and bring back hope and pride in our people.

Name: deo
City/State/Country: flour-flower city
IP Address: 74.65.5.42

Comments

Can the Philippines stand up to China? When a captain of a ship has to asked for a time-out because his ship needs refueling it only tells the insects one thing: these Filipinos should produce a sitcom for insect audience back home. At Poro Point, the merchant will probably not sell them provisions without showing the mola first. I mean, come on, it's a joke to confront even just the "fishing boats" with few days provisions. Pati ba naman pera ng rusty bucket eh, pag-iintirisan pa? BTW, and this is not a joke, only one nuke armed ship of the insect sink not only the Philippine navy but the whole country. My suggestion still stands: Let the Philippine insect negotiate with the Chinese insect. Philippine insect has a lot to lose.

Name: Jorge Villanueva
City/State/Country: Canada
IP Address: 142.162.188.229

Comments

We need to come out now as a " bottom feeding country in Asia." We need to bring back our pride as a nation and the respectability we earned in the 50's. Let's go after the graftors and corruptors of the nation's wealth. They should be made to feel ashamed and they should be jailed. Look at all the politicians we have now. How many have had questionable pasts? How many are back and smiling.

Name: Marie
City/State/Country: Culion
IP Address: 64.40.183.70

Comments

"Can The Philippines Stand UP To China" ? Ha ha ha ha! SURE why not?!? Declare war, send token invading force to Hong Kong and a contingent of Boy Scouts as occupation force of the Scarborough Shoal and top it all with an armada of Vinta supported by bangka (yung may katig para mukhang malaki)--- then shoot a few rounds until all ammo supplies are finished-- that will show those Chinese. Then retreat , hoist the white flag and negotiate for rehabilitation aid from both China and Uncle Sam!! Noynoy can lead the charge!

Name: mockingmaya
City/State/Country: taft avenue, manila
IP Address: 67.182.75.243

Comments

Communist China & its Red Army are aware of different techniques of propaganda such as diplomatic propaganda, or overt & covert propaganda, which must be reinforced by propaganda of action. Overt propaganda is essential, for example, research or spy vessels, for attacking enemies. Communist China is using its traditional propaganda by destroying the confidence, creating crisis, conflict of weak nations like the Philippine Republic: to play on the prestige of military power, or naval power, or Red soldier, etc.

Name: ReyOfBatoCatPhil
City/State/Country: Reno, Nevada, USA
IP Address: 99.46.25.26

Comments

We can overcome this aggression by putting all those who, in one way or another, sent America out of the Philippines in the front row of the fire fight between the Phil. and Chinese military and then let us see how those Marcos supporters do. This Chinese military has no respect whatsoever for PI military "coz we have no backbones, no more America behind us. They know how corrupt and stupid we are, puro magnanakaw kaliwat kanan, up and down. Pagmayroon gumagawa ng kabutihan gagawin mali, hindi baga tulungan na masmapabuti kundi ililigaw pa paramakakurakot. We are leading or close to a point of no return that we could not make it right anymore, I hope not.

Name: HMS
City/State/Country: New York NY
IP Address: 67.241.96.149

Comments

Let's look at the positive side. Since the Philippines is so mired in endless, limitless corruption that does not seem to have any local solution, since all its formerly venerable institutions are getting nothing but lip service and a wink of the eye, perhaps what it needs is foreign occupation. A country "run like heaven" by non-Filipinos.

Name: Gene
City/State/Country: Ontario, Canada
IP Address: 174.93.113.120

Comments

I just hope that Pres. Aquino continues upgrading the PN and PAF asap. The country cannot just standby and be bullied by Red China in its rightful claim of the disputed island. Communist China do not want to settle amicably the disputed island before the U.N. because they knew they'll lose. I know some pessimists would laugh but they are not true Filipino in thought, in words, and in deeds. (part of our oath of allegiance). You can laugh but it is disgraceful not to fight. We have to unite and urge Pres. Aquino to acquire more warships and airplanes till we get the nos. sufficient to fight back. Criticize me but I would not accept that Communist China dominate us. Whatever projects or infrastructures that Communist China build on the disputed island must be sabotage and must be destroyed.

Name: kali
City/State/Country: Hawaii
IP Address: 66.91.35.33

Comments

In the news; “Philippine Navy was prevented by Chinese vessels from arresting the Chinese fishermen for illegal fishing at Scarborough shoal; Chinese government claims sovereignty of Scarborough shoal”. Scarborough shoal is not even part of the disputed Spratly Island. It is only 124 miles offshore of Zambales. So, definitely the Chinese invaded the Philippines. The Chinese sovereignty claim is “bullshit”, just an excuse for their invasion. PNoy show that you have “balls”, send back the Navy ship BRP Gregorio del Pilar and fire a few rounds over them. If this is the start of war with the Chinese then let it be. We have ASEAN and UN on our side, so let’s pick a fight against this invaders!

Name: deo
City/State/Country: flour-flower city
IP Address: 74.65.5.42

Comments

In the news: "Philippine Navy In Standoffs With Chinese Ships". The obviousity is as clear is mud: "dehadong-dehado" ang Philippine Navy. In fact I will bet my last aluminum centavo: One insect ship vs. entire PH navy, lo-dies sa insect my centavo. Bakit mag-tapang-tapangan? Wala namang ibubuga? Why not let the insect who control the Philippine economy negotiate with the insect from China? After all Philippine insect have everything to lose, unless of course both insect are just playing moro-moro. I remember in the 50s & 60s, humor is PH insect displayed the picture of Chiang Kai Shek but the reverse of the frame is the picture of Mao Che Tong. Seguradong walang talo, right?

Name: GFJBHEDF
City/State/Country: Hercules
IP Address: 67.188.19.40

Comments

Stand off at Pantag Shoal, aka Scarborough Shoal, 124 nautical miles from Subic.., 400 natical miles from China's closes Hainan (island) province; Philippines vs China. Philippines arrested significant number of Chinese fishermen poaching here in 2000 -2001, which is well within Philippine 200 nautical mile UNCLOS. Will the P'Noy Gov't do likewise, or curl its tail between its shaking legs? > LINK

Name: Tambay sa Kanto
City/State/Country: Abu Dhabi
IP Address: 86.99.159.69

Comments

Itoy kwentong barbero. According to my Indian friend, one time in the past during the time of Ghandi, high profiled personnel from China visited India and was highly welcomed. But after that visitor left, immediately India was attacked by China and big portion of their territory was grabbed. Accordingly, Ghandi said that peace can be attained only if India is powerful which later on led to their acquisition of nuclear weapons. In our case, for Philippines to deal with diplomatic solution with China will not work as China cannot be trusted. China will just fool the weak Philippines by saying this and that but will do the opposite.

Name: Phil Researcher
City/State/Country: LA County, Ca USA
IP Address: 98.119.17.19

Comments

RE: Standing up to the Chinese.. "A credible AFP must be the starting point of any diplomacy.." Let's analyze that--is the AFP credible? First you have to ask..have they stopped the P5 million stipend for the chief and the pabaon.. the figure is 10 million welcome & 50 million upon retirement,... these are all accusations.. when he killed himself the late Angelo Reyes never denied those amounts of money.. I guess they believe they are entitled to it..Have the AFP Generals ended all those shenanigans? Is there any senate or congressional investigation? Why not?

Name: Lydia Mandanas
City/State/Country: United States
IP Address: 67.125.20.195

Comments

The recent standoff between China and the Philippines, wherein the Chinese vessels were able to leave with Philippine treasures without the Navy or Coastguard vessels being able to arrest them, only shows that the Philippines cannot really defend itself. Shame on those who rally against the presence of the American army. I am sure those who rally want themselves or their siblings to come to the U.S. The United States is still the best and trusted friend and defender of the Philippines. The presence of the American forces is a deterrent to other nations which would otherwise have ill motive against the Philippines. Instead of rallying and noynoying, why don't these people go to work and help in the economy?

Name: mockingmaya
City/State/Country: taft avenue, manila
IP Address: 67.182.75.243

Comments

You don't need to be a student of International Relations & War College to understand that Communist China is utilizing its traditional propaganda technique of agitation, for example, if Communist China wants to galvanize energies to mobilize its nation for international conflict, it will use the propaganda of agitation. I do believe that psychological war is the purpose of the Red China's spy naval vessels cloaked as research ships stationed in the Spratly islands.

Name: 1 UP
City/State/Country: GOTHAM CITY
IP Address: 207.38.182.120

Comments

We can't be hawkish and create an international incident that will draw super powers into the incident at the Scarborough shoal. Diplomacy should be used instead of mano-a-mano, physical or military. False pride? Bravado? Use your reason but not emotion folks!

Name: Jun Sapote
City/State/Country: Angeles City
IP Address: 124.197.32.158

Comments

Asan na mga matatapang na senador at congresista natin? Matatapang lang pala mga mukha nyo na mangurakot! Declare Chinese ambassador "persona non-grata" ordered to leave or send back to China. Arrest those fishermen poaching in our waters and put them in jail. Fire cannons at those Chinese navy ships trespassing our exclusive territorial waters. This is it! Mga duwag ba tayo? Yan ba tinuro ng mga bayani natin?

Name: JRH
City/State/Country: Montreal, Canada
IP Address: 70.81.198.36

Comments

This was the biggest deployment of a total of 2 ships of the mighty Phil Navy against the Chinese Navy Fleet. Our navy is fully armed & ready to fight a naval battle with nothing but raw nerve, courage, & an ill-fitted determination to win. Now these brave Filipinos have seen finally the worst enemy & it is us. The bottom line is our military is ill-equipped & poorly armed..no jets, no missiles, no submarines, etc. The top brass in the military are known for stealing money, enriching themselves with big bonuses & stolen money to purchase expensive properties in the U.S. So, why even ask if we can stand up to China. Let's finish first our long-standing conflict with the Muslim separatists & the communist-led NPA.

Name: pinaskongmahal
City/State/Country: usa
IP Address: 199.96.203.220

Comments

Spratley is 110 miles away from Subic and 450 miles from Beijing. What further right do the Chinese have to claim Phil as their province like Taiwan? Mali yata. When the US Pacific forces occupied Subic, Clark and Sangley Point under a treaty, the Spratlys were untouchable. But when the minority communist and leftist members of Congress (Erap, Sumulong, Diokno, etc.) abrogated the treaty under Cory, the US Forces left. Now with our rustbucket ships and 1 Tora-Tora OV-10 plane, everybody is claiming ownership of the Spratlys. Can these leftists legislators fight for us to keep the Spratlys?

Name: GFJBHEDF
City/State/Country: Hercules
IP Address: 67.188.19.40

Comments

Unless Philippines can enforce its UNCLOS/EEZ claim, it means nothing to China. So as not to be characterized as an invasion, China saturates Scarborough Shoal with fishing and research vessels in the name of science. It is not an armed invasion. Therefore, no VFA. China is not the only one having a big laugh at the expense of P'Noy et al.

Name: Reynard
City/State/Country: Palawan, Philippines
IP Address: 212.11.179.82

Comments

I think the Chinese fishing boats that entered to our water territory are not only an ordinary fishing boats, Maybe they have some other purpose, but pretending to be as fishermen.

Name: Jorge Villanueva
City/State/Country: Canada
IP Address: 142.162.179.78

Comments

Can the Philippines stand up to China? That is not difficult to answer, but look at what we are standing on or who is propping us up on our feet—it's the mighty United States. It's akin to the proverbial story of the heron and the carabao. The Philippines can challenge anybody but we need the Americans to back us up. We are not ready on our own for our wealth and pride have all been eroded by graft, corruption and politics, side by side.

Name: Steve R
City/State/Country: California
IP Address: 98.234.19.64

Comments

In 1991, these were the Senators who voted to end U.S. bases in the PH. Agapito Aquino, Sotero Laurel, Ernesto Maceda Jr., Aquilino Pimentel Jr., Rene Saguisag, Jovito Salonga, Wigberto Tanada, Victor Zaga, Juan Ponce Enrile, Joseph Estrada, Orlando Mercado & Teofisto Guingona. “Child prostitution, exploitation of Filipino labor, and national sovereignty” were among several concerns that were cited by the anti-bases commissioners. Where is the PH in terms of ‘sovereignty’? Answer, the MILF is about to be on their own, NPAs are able to kill soldiers & civilians, Abu Sayaffs are able to kidnap for ransom, human trafficking & child prostitution goes on & on & the Visconde Massacre, ( who got rich from it) & Magindanao Massacre made headlines.

Name: Tristan De Vera
City/State/Country: Dubai UAE
IP Address: 94.203.216.154

Comments

During this time. We must know our real enemies. No doubt to China’s might. We don’t stand a chance both political and militarily. To confront it militarily we need an ally like America. In the international and political front. We need a patriotic leader that we can trust. Rid the government of communist infiltrators. Doesn't it make you sick watching the news. The commies in the guise of LFS, Gabriela, KMU, etc. Are all up in arms and prepared to die to stop America and Philippine war games. All of this in the guise of independence. Bullsh*t. Pilipinos wake up the commies are in our midst. To all the brainwashed LFS, KMU, Gabriela cadre, ask yourself: who do you really serve by curtailing every action of our government? So that the Philippine will be easily subjugated by China.

Name: marty
City/State/Country: khobar
IP Address: 166.87.149.217

Comments

How can anyone expect the Philippine AFP to stand up to China when they cannot even control internal problems like the Abu Sayyaf, MILF and NPA. The AFP has no creditability anywhere. Its all about leadership....overall Military, Congressional and Presidential Leadership is lacking throughout the entire chain of command. Why did the Philippines not match China warship for warship during the latest confrontation. We had the ships.....we also lack the leadership to do so.

Name: tonyo
City/State/Country: pinas
IP Address: 111.68.59.98

Comments

I wonder what is China’s justification why it does not respect Pinas’ sovereignty over the Spratly’s, which is within the 200 nautical miles EEZ of Pinas pursuant to the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) in which China is a signatory? Pinas should file a protest over China’s violation of this Treaty at ng magkaintindihan na ang buong mundo. Will the United Nations allows these violations or will it uphold the integrity of the UN and the treaties it is mandated to protect? China cannot fight the UN. Takutan lamang ang ginagawa ng mga insects, like when it engaged SOUTH VIETNAM’S NAVY INTO A NAVAL MASSACRE, (see footage). What did South Vietnam do about this incident? LINK

Name: skokie
City/State/Country: chicago
IP Address: 70.143.71.59

Comments

Chinese invest money to guard and research our territory. Phils invest money to secure "pabaon" to our high ranking military officers/politicians. No, di natin kaya Chinese. Di nga maaresto at mabawi yung giant clams/baby sharks na ninakaw nila duh! Eh 3 research ships nga biglang nagutom mga navy natin at sabi takbo to resupply food/fuel sa Poro Point La Union. The least we can do is to acquire a fleet of F16s, some gunboats, n a dozen more destroyers/ frigates. so we can defend reasonably if provoked/attacked! No doubt we have the money if walang corruption left and right sa Pinas. Chinese will not back down, communism sa USSR humina, pero Chinese communism remains until now. They have no plans to slowdown and get bullied but to bully us.

Name: myra
City/State/Country: sa banda rito
IP Address: 69.255.140.215

Comments

tayo na ring mga Pinoy ang may kasalanan nito, dahil pinalayas natin ang mga Kano ngayon wala ng dumedepensa na sa atin at ilang mga isla na ang mga kinabig ng China at wala tayong panama sa kanila. Ang susunod nilang kukunin buong bansa na!!! Na magiging kumunistang Pinas na tayo!! Hay naku , naway maging bukas na ang ating isipan.

Name: Reynard Montes
City/State/Country: Palawan, Philippines
IP Address: 212.11.178.109

Comments

Ang China hindi makukuha sa mapayapang usapan, ewan ko ba dito sa mga negotiator natin puros paki usap na lang wala din naman mangyayari, Dapat kausapin na natin ang United States na handa ba silang tumulong kung sakaling magkaroon nang conflict ang Pilipinas at China?

Name: kali
City/State/Country: Hawaii
IP Address: 66.91.35.33

Comments

With the departure of the Chinese vessels, Filipinos should not raise victory flag yet, cuz the Chinese will probably say “I’ll be back”. Diplomacy has its limitation, and the Chinese were smart to claim sovereignty of the shoal to get their fishermen out of harm’s way, meaning not arrested by Philippine authorities. The big question here is if the Chinese come back and stay for good then what will PNoy do. Let’s forget about arming the Philippine military to the teeth; still it’s no match against the Chinese. Since UN set the law, then UN should police the area so that the Chinese will not intrude again. If the Chinese insist then it would be war against UN and ASEAN countries while we watch in the sidelines. Deo ANOSAYMO?

Name: edgardo
City/State/Country: makati
IP Address: 180.194.170.141

Comments

The Philippines needs a good leader with political will. the AFP cannot buy modern equipments such as jets and modern warships because political leaders are corrupt. They are the ones who budget money for the defense of the country. Also AFP officials from Col to star ranks are in the hands of political leaders because of commission of appointment. I hope Filipinos will choose better leaders with political will.

Name: GFJBHEDF
City/State/Country: Hercules
IP Address: 67.188.19.40

Comments

The moment the Philippines leaves Scarborough shoal as per China's demand.., while China's boat(s) still there.., then in essence China won the saber rattling. Philippines need to continue rotating/relieving, 24/7, Coast Guard vessels in the Scarborough shoal till the Chinese vessels depart, and any time foreign vessels are in the area. The moment China open fire on Coast Guards ships implementing the laws of the Philippines.., hell breaks loose. VFA will rain on their parade. Chinese growing economy will come to a halt, as the the 3rd world war will have begun. Is China ready to destroy itself because of the Spratlys and Scarborough shoal. I don't think so. Confucius is no fool.

Name: Phil Researcher
City/State/Country: LA County, Ca
IP Address: 98.119.17.19

Comments

RE: Can the Ph stand up against China.. The obvious answer.. of course not. China is one of the countries in the UN who has a veto power...So even if the other 5 or 6 countries in the Security Council says one way with China's Veto power China can say no way. The PH is a 3rd world country where as China now is the biggest creditor of the USA...Will the U.S. A go to war with Ph against China.. The sad answer is no way.. The USA will pretend only but it won't go against China if we are only talking about the Spratlys Islands. So the best and only way is to settle the conflict without any gunpowder involved.

Name: Paul
City/State/Country: Austin, TX
IP Address: 24.153.226.199

Comments

Who are we kidding? America won't back the Philippines up, even if the Chinese invaded Metro Manila. America owes the Chinese too much.

Name: antonio jr.
City/State/Country: Manila
IP Address: 112.205.85.94

Comments

Are you KIDDING ? With some quarters disliking the presence of Americans from being involved, how else can we show our muscles in a situation like this? Come, come my dear fellows", with two old warships, somebody has begun to feel brave enough to face Goliath.

Name: Jorge Villanueva
City/State/Country: Canada
IP Address: 142.162.188.237

Comments

The question is, can the Philippines stand up against China? The answer is, definitely yes. But look underneath and one can see the country is propped-up or standing on the mighty United States. This is akin to the proverbial story of the Heron and the Carabao with the bird bragging he is the tallest animal in the forest but he is really on top of the carabao's back. I don't blame the military for their predicament because like many other areas of the country all have been stripped clean by graft and corruption. Support anti-corruption!!!

Name: eddie King
City/State/Country: Las Vegas, Nevada
IP Address: 24.234.108.78

Comments

Can we call those so called nationalistic people like Joseph Estrada, Aquino jr, Tanada and others who calls for the removal of US bases, TO DO THEIR ACT OF PATRIOTISM AND GO TO SPRATLY ISLANDS and fight the Chinese NOW. WHERE ARE THESE PEOPLE NOW. F????????????!!!!!!!!! these nationalists.

Name: deo
City/State/Country: flour-flower city
IP Address: 74.65.5.42

Comments

Come to think of it, there is no country on earth that RP can really stand up against. If a country is militarily weak, RP beat it in G&C ranking.

Name: Jorge Villanueva
City/State/Country: Canada
IP Address: 142.162.188.237

Comments

Addendum about Philippines vis-à-vis China. Once prosecution is made against corrupt officials the government with the people's support should forge on. Like a massive dose of anti-biotic it can't be stopped or reduced prematurely otherwise it will only create resistant bugs or super corrupters. Once the body politic is clean, the nation will be a haven for foreign investors. Of course, more jobs means better standard of living, and fewer exodus abroad . Finally, all this exhortation ends with a better equipment for our military and naval forces.

Name: A. Poli
City/State/Country: Anywhere
IP Address: 184.148.77.181

Comments

On PNoy's handling of China's incursion to Phil territory. - will this turn out to be another booboo? Gosh, what the heck is the president doing about it? Imagine Filipino citizens being shooed out of our own backyard! Because your neighbor from another time zone says its theirs. What's the strategy? Curl your tail like a dog! Gosh.. This is becoming too much to handle Mr. Co Huang Co clan member. Can't you use your cultural influence? After all sometimes blood is thicker than water.

Name: GFJBHEDF
City/State/Country: Hercules
IP Address: 67.188.19.40

Comments

Dear Tonyo, "China is signatory to treaty.. duty bound to respect provision." 100% agree, but China won't. "UN may intercede.. for implementation of treaty." 100% agree. I'll keep my thumbs up. "That's the purpose of UN." 100% agree, but China doesn't know that.

Name: tonyO
City/State/Country: pinas
IP Address: 111.68.59.99

Comments

Tarantado talaga ang mga insects nato. This area is within the 200 nautical mile from Pinas baseline hence within its Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) to which China is a signatory. Pinas musty not give way even at the cost of a firefight with the Chinese. China can’t win the diplomatic impasse and legal issue. China will be a pariah in the world community if it does.

Name: GFJBHEDF
City/State/Country: Hercules
IP Address: 67.188.19.40

Comments

The Philippine navy will never go to war against any foreign nation, outside protecting/policing its own UNCLOS/EEZ. Therefore, it is time to disband and integrate the navy to the Philippine Coast Guard, and put the whole shebang to work.., patrolling Philippine waters, enforcing sea laws, instead of being useless.., moored.., waiting for a conflict/war that may never come. It can always revert to Naval operation automatically if war is declared. Any foreign nation that declares war against the Philippines, declares war on VFA. So, go ahead Limahong, fire your guns against Filipinos in their UNCLOS.EEZ as you did to the Vietnamese in the 80s.

Name: Lydia Mandanas
City/State/Country: United States
IP Address: 71.138.132.173

Comments

Having this problem with China only reminds me of our National Anthem, portions of which read "Sa manlulupig, di ka pasisiil" and "Aming ligaya na pag may mang-aapi, ang mamatay ng dahil sa yo". The lyrics inspired our national heroes to go forth, fight and defend our land without counting the costs. I am happy that our leaders are trying to settle the dispute thru peaceful means. But what if this effort fails? Do they have a Plan B? When we were little kids and got bullied by bad guys, we turned to our big brothers for support. May be, we can do the same now?

Name: letlet
City/State/Country: uk
IP Address: 78.105.230.164

Comments

At long last, our government is going to file a protest to the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea, in which the seat is at Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg in the Federal Republic of Germany. China is going to continually harass and bully Philippine no matter what efforts the government officials will do (lodging protest to the ambassador of china to Pinas). The Chinese really want the territorial areas of Spratly, Kalayaan and Panatag Shoal that the United Conventions on Law of the Sea says belong to Philippines for their own development and utilization. Go Philippines, file your protest now with the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea.

Name: alanz seville
City/State/Country: San Diego, Californi
IP Address: 99.101.12.154

Comments

This should be a wake up call to all Filipinos and to all government high officials...You need to modernize your air force, navies etc. in order to protect your own territory and do not just rely on your allies. Scarborough shoal is just 124 nautical miles from Zambales, set up an air base next to Zambales w/ 3 or 4 squadron of f16 or f18 that should make the Chinese think twice before they comeback to Scarborough shoal and Spratly island....

Name: mockingmaya
City/State/Country: taft avenue, manila
IP Address: 67.182.75.243

Comments

I do agree with PNL that "public service should be treated as a vocation where only the truly dedicated are given the chance to serve", not like some Filipino Naval Captains, who're selling government fuel at sea (see corrupt Naval Captains who sold government fuel to civilian fishing boat owners in Palawan, Zamboanga, etc.)

Name: Dakila K
City/State/Country: Pilipinas
IP Address: 27.33.69.203

Comments

Mga kabayan tingnan nyu ang Falkland Islands thousand klm ang layo mula sa England "Islas Malvinas ayon sa Argentinian" Oo sa geographical connotation at prinsipyo ng mga Argentino ay napakalapit sa katutuhanan, Islas Malvinas ay part ng Argentina, hahaha nakipaglaban ang Argentina sa England, nanalo ba? luhaang ibinalik ang mga Argentinong bangkay "mga patay" sa mainland. Hindi ko na alam kung may naitulong na solution ang United Nation sa Argentina sa pag ki'claim na part ng Argentina ang Falkland Islands/Islas Malvinas.

Name: Jun Sapote
City/State/Country: Angeles City
IP Address: 124.197.32.158

Comments

Bakit ba tayo natatakot sa China? sila abusado at makapal ang mukha! Alam na alam nila sa atin ang Scarborough Shoal at Spratly Islands .... nilabanan natin ang mga Kastila, Amerikano at Hapon.....sila pa kaya? Di na dapat kinakausap pa sila. They must leave our territory now!!!! They have nothing to do in that area! If they shoot us ..the whole world will condemn these Chinese. If we allow these we will become like Tibet....sooner or later!!!!

Name: Raul Lacuna
City/State/Country: Vancouver, Canada
IP Address: 23.16.3.220

Comments

Kawawa naman ang mga Pilipino. Ninanakawan na ng mga dayuhan, ninanakawan pa rin ng mga kapwa Pilipino sa gobiyerno.

Name: mockingmaya
City/State/Country: taft avenue, manila
IP Address: 67.182.75.243

Comments

Again, I do agree with the editor's insight that "diplomacy alone without a credible retaliatory threat will likely be dismissed by the Chinese..." This is realpolitic. Every diplomacy, or engaged foreign policy requires a military profile. Japan recognizes this fact to counter the growing post-Cold War security issues in Asia (see "sogo anzen hosho.") You can't defeat Communism without studying the nature of your enemies culture, loyalty, education, propaganda, military, the motive of immigration, and so on.

Name: John B.
City/State/Country: Sherman Oaks. Ca,US
IP Address: 76.216.152.14

Comments

It must have been in China's long forgotten memory when they were subject to unspeakable violation and dehumanizing massacre by an 'ethnocentric' and expansionist Japan in Nanking and Manchuria in this past century. Surprisingly, China having one of the biggest land mass on the planet still needs to own two more isolated little islands 'somewhere in the Asian Pacific'! Apparently they need more factory space for their consumer goods (knock-offs not withstanding). If the U.S. picks our side, then the Mexicans will demand for the return of Texas and California!

Name: tonyo
City/State/Country: pinas
IP Address: 111.68.59.97

Comments

Pinas will encounter big trouble with China on its territorial dispute over the Scarborough Shoal. The recent history shows China’s EXPANSIONIST attitudes towards these disputed archipelago. Even the USA is complaining China’s maritime behavior in East Asia. Papanot kaya ito? Well, try diplomacy. That’s the most Pinas can do.

Name: Steve R
City/State/Country: California
IP Address: 98.234.19.64

Comments

My gut feeling tells me, YES, the PH can & should stand up to the PRC. The book, titled “No Guts No Glory” helped me believe; we can stand up to China although I have only read the book Preview at this point. If China had not fired their first shot by now, I believe that their strategy is not to fire the first shot. I think that PNoy was wrong to state that the PH ruled out the possibility of going to war with China. AFP’s Psychological Warfare Officer must have recommended against making a statement that the PH will not go to war to protect its territorial rights at Panatag Shoal. PH needed carefully ‘calculated & worded statements’ designed to make China ‘THINK’, what the PH is willing to risk to protect Panatag.

Name: JRH
City/State/Country: Toronto, Ontario
IP Address: 174.95.64.101

Comments

The military option is out of the question. It must be settled in the International Court under International Law under Laws of the Seas (200Miles Inclusion Zone).

Name: lee buyagan
City/State/Country: la trinidad
IP Address: 77.30.108.249

Comments

No one to be blamed for the bullying by China except those corrupt past presidents and most retired and active high ranking military officials, let the Ampatuan clan stand up against China,,,they are better equipped with arms than our military.

Name: sbejar
City/State/Country: chicago
IP Address: 99.105.68.41

Comments

Pa-ano di tayo bababuyin ng mga Intsek, tungkol sa Spratlys, eh mula sa baranggay tanod hanggang sa presidente ay corrupt. Alam ng mga Intsek na mahina ang foundation ng moralidad at resolva ng mga Pinoy. Noon nasa Pinas pa ang mga Americano ay ginagawa nilang firing range ang lugar, eh bakit ngayon at wala na sila eh gustong kamkamin ng Itsek ang lugar. Maliwanag na nagpabaya ang mga nakaraang gobyerno at umasa tayong sobra sa mga kano kaya ngayon, nakanganga tayo. Gaya ng kasabihan sa American, You snooze your lose.

Name: 1 UP
City/State/Country: GOTHAM CITY
IP Address: 207.38.182.120

Comments

The matter of territorial rights and poaching of the China in the Philippines either by some fishermen or some "scientific" researchers is best resolved through the UN via the International Court where Santiago is one of the judges. China could be painted as an "aggressor" a bully or any other name for that matter. It would not defy the court's ruling. China would not want to be seen that way. It is bad for China's image.

Name: LPiF
City/State/Country: LosAngeles/Mla
IP Address: 121.1.11.38

Comments

All the Americans can do is to publish a paradox for the world to hear, pretend they are on our side hope it will placate China's anger. PH would not stand a chance, China is too powerful and well equipped, but if they attack us, do you think the Americans will just ignore it? I doubt!

Name: Vanessa Lee
City/State/Country: Kuwait
IP Address: 149.147.168.71

Comments

The Disputed Spratlys is within the Philippine Waters. The Philippines is the legal owner of the islands in the Spratlys as it is within 200 Nautical Mile Exclusive Economic Zone. China should accept the truth they cannot be and will never be the owner of the island in point. They knew they have no right but still insist they believe we Pilipinos are ignorant and weak. They are so hostile, provocative showing the world the magnitude of their arsenal. It might be true we cannot stand with China when it comes to gun powder the least we can do is to be very diplomatic to solve this issue what more we have? cont....

Name: Vanessa Lee
City/State/Country: Kuwait
IP Address: 149.147.168.71

Comments

Contd... Like this situation, these senators, congressmen and other public servants are they not conscientious enough that we cannot elevate the position of our country? Stop the pork barrel, make it case to case basis.

Name: roni
City/State/Country: quezon city
IP Address: 124.104.96.34

Comments

Matagal na tayong sinakup ng mga tsekwa na yan. Napapalibutan narin ang malakanyang, at maraming Pilipino ang alipin ng mga tsekwa na yan dito mismo sa sarili nating bayan. Huwag natin hayaang sakupin rin nila pati ang ating karagatan na pinagkukunan ng ating kabuhayan.

Name: Manuel C. Diaz
City/State/Country: Antipolo City
IP Address: 180.191.201.8

Comments

When the US Navy was still stationed at Subic Bay Chinese intrusion into the Scarborough Shoal was unheard of Scarborough Shoal is only 124nautical miles from Subic US Naval Base. Our nationalist senators and congressmen/women during the Aquino 1 regime (Cory Aquino's rule were congratulating themselves for their nationalistic fervor in kicking out the Americans from Subic and Clark Air Bases. Now you want the Americans to intervene! With the Chinese Navy now patrolling the Scarborough Shoal the Philippines can do nothing to the Chinese intrusion. Scarborough Shoal is as good as lost thanks to our patriotic idiocy.

Name: Jorge Villanueva
City/State/Country: Canada
IP Address: 142.162.183.209

Comments

The Filipinos should be 100% behind Pres. Aquino in his plan to assert the country's sovereignty over the Spratly island. It seems he is interested to pursue all possibilities through diplomatic channels but is not afraid to defend it by force, if need be. Of course, militarily its akin to a " David and Goliath " situation but reasonable countries would see and be able to understand how sensible and courageous the stand is.

Name: rodeones
City/State/Country: phils
IP Address: 141.0.9.38

Comments

1960's Phil navy was one of the best in Asia. now, our navy is the weakest in Asia. in other words napag iwanan tayo. nkakalungkot isipin, pasensya na po nkatulog yata tayo sa kangkungan eh! what happened in Scarborough shoal is a wakeup call to all Phil govt officials and to each every one of us! STOP CORRUPTION! UPGRADE OUR DEFENSE AND WEAPONRY! LETS FIGHT FOR OUR LANDS AND TERRITORIES! MABUHAY ANG PILIPINAS!

Name: Vanessa Lee
City/State/Country: Kuwait
IP Address: 46.186.248.243

Comments

We cannot deny the fact that our country could not stand alone I believe the authorities should return the defunct US Base. There was a provocation from China Navy sometime in 1988 that 64 lives of innocent Vietnamese perished with regard to Spratly Island. I cannot remember whether China showed same provocation with us as they are now when the US base still with us. Correct me if I am wrong.

Name: WDC
City/State/Country: California
IP Address: 66.126.39.95

Comments

Can Philippines stand-up China? This is should be the direct questions to those Filipino people who always criticize the US. I just came back from the Philippines and witnessed those Filipinos demonstrating against the joint US and Philippine military training (Balikatan), it is very shameful for us as Filipinos. We are weak as a nation. If these Filipino cowards think they can defend the Philippines against any foreign aggressions without any US assistance, let them then show to us their capable to do.

Name: Jun Sapote
City/State/Country: Angeles City
IP Address: 124.197.32.158

Comments

Mga kabayan di nyo ba naiisip na pag sinakop tayo ng China...lugaw ang kakainin natin araw-araw, habang ang malaking bahagi ng ating ani ay ibebenta ng kumunistang gobyerno sa abroad as an export? At yan ang ginagastos nila sa kanilang militar. Ibalik ang EDSA REVOLUTION!!! Sa lahat na ayaw panaman nating pinoy ay pag inaabuso na ang kabaitan natin. Di nyo napapansin na sinimulan nila na poaching poaching lang nung una ngayon inaangkin na nila kasi lagi nating pinakakawalan pag me nahuhuling mga chinese fishermen sa area. Palayasin ang chinese ambassador !!!! at lahat ng chinese sa Pilipinas!!!! Walang pinoy ang nagmimigrate sa China!!! mga chinese ang nagmimigrate sa atin!!!!! Ayokong mag lugaw araw-araw!!!!!!!!! mabuti pang mamatay ng lumalaban!!!!!.

Name: Steve R
City/State/Country: California
IP Address: 98.234.19.64

Comments

Until the Panatag dispute is settled in a way that PH sovereignty was not violated, I will not eat Chinese food and/or buy Chinese made products. I’ll look at the product label to make sure an item is not made in China before buying an item. If non-government organizations will encourage their members to do the same, I am sure the bullying that we are getting at Panatag will gradually stop. If global Filipino will response to China’s bullying at Panatag with a total boycott of Chinese products, Chinese fishermen will surely move out of Panatag.

Name: Manuel C. Diaz
City/State/Country: Antipolo City
IP Address: 180.191.51.178

Comments

Going to war against China are we insane? how will the Islas de ladrones support the war effort by OFW remittances? The US bases in the Philippines was a deterrent to Chinese incursion into Islas de ladrones territorial waters. Now the Indios will surrender Scarborough reef in silence next is the Kalaya-an Island aka Spratley. Our Idiotic leaders during the St. Cory regime never saw it that the US Bases was a deterrent against China.

Name: WDC
City/State/Country: California
IP Address: 75.38.77.18

Comments

Philippines is broke because of their corrupt gov't and can't afford to face the military power of any country unless assisted by another very powerful country like the US. Now that Philippines is facing war against China, Filipinos MUST and MUST know where their priorities are? I don't foresee why the US military defend the Philippines while the Filipino politicians are stealing left and right and Filipinos as a whole don't give a sh#t to their own future.

Name: Henry De Ocho
City/State/Country: Buenavista, Phil.
IP Address: 37.40.110.217

Comments

My small suggestion is, that all current and incoming RP Senators, RP Congressmen, and Pres Noynoy should use all their pork barrels in their remaining terms, in funding the acquisition (for now) of BRAND NEW and MORDERN 5 Battleships, 50 Sea Patrol Boats, 20 New F-16s, 10 New Attack Helicopters, 10 New Tanks all equipped with the necessary guns and fire power, also with all the necessary warfare electronics, + training on how to use them, for a BIG CHANGE. Pag ganito ang ginawa nyo ay hindi na ako makikinig sa salitang RP NOYNOYING President, RP Tongressmen at RP Senatongs. Giving you all my BIG THANKS. God bless you all.

Name: John
City/State/Country: Los Angeles
IP Address: 24.43.32.149

Comments

That the Philippines could invest in any military force strong enough to deter China is laughable. The amount of money China has, the amount of resources, the degree of newer technology China retains... it surpasses the resources of the Philippines many, many, times over. The Philippines' only hope to stand up to China is to encourage a strong posture from the Americans. But the Philippines didn't win points with the Americans when they kicked them out of Subic Bay. The Chinese wouldn't dare make such a close incursion to a U.S. naval base! Now that they're gone, of course China's going to assert itself. The Philippine flagship is a 40 year-old frigate! The lesson here is "do not bite the hand that feeds you." Or more specifically, do not bite the hand that protects you.

Name: E. Tan
City/State/Country: Ongpin, Manila
IP Address: 70.160.144.157

Comments

Can PH stand against China? Yes it can for about 1 minuto, then get knocked off cold the following minuto. The best PH can do is deport the Marcos, Arroyo and Estrada families to the Spratlys.

Name: tonyo
City/State/Country: pinas
IP Address: 111.68.59.99

Comments

Joma Sison disputes claim of ownership and sovereignty over the Spratlys and the Paracels, based on historical right, “as this would bel like Italy claiming all areas previously occupied by the Roman Empire.” Phreng Deo. This is contrary to your submission. Imagine. Italy claiming ownership of the Continental Europe and Africa, including the middle east, only because it once ruled over these continents. On the contrary, the Public International law/the treaty on law of the sea 200 nautical miles doctrine prevails. In short, China which is far far far away from the disputed sea area where the Spratlys and the Paracels are located. Sa aking pananaw, walang karapatan ang China at matatalo ito sa legal isyu.

Name: Steve R
City/State/Country: California
IP Address: 98.234.19.64

Comments

In 1991 it took 12 Senators, the magnificent 12 or dirty dozen to close all the U S bases in the PH. The next big ‘bubo’ could be done by one Senator Escudero who is talking about giving away one half of Panatag Shoal to China. In his own words, he is proposing “for the country’s joint exploration with China, rather than taking a confrontational stand on the Panatag Shoal issue”. “Can we just cooperate to explore the area and together benefit from it while we are finding out and resolving who owns it” In short, he is saying that; PH is not sure if Panatag belongs to Filipinos. Well somebody get this Senator in front of Miriam while he is talking that ‘trash”. He definitely deserves an earful from her.

Name: Phil Researcher
City/State/Country: LA County, Ca USA
IP Address: 98.119.17.19

Comments

RE: Why Ph kicked out Americans from U.S. Bases.. I believe the main reason was self-respect. The Ph Government at that time in 1990 were demanding an increase in U.S. bases payments in the PH to an amount close to or equal to that amount the U.S. was paying Spain for American bases in Spain.. The U.S negotiators were of the belief that the Ph representatives were bluffing.. well in 1991 they were all gone.. It was bad for Filipinos who were waiting for their visas (those Filipinos who were civilian employees of U.S. Bases). but overall it was good in the sense that he red light district in Angeles City and Subic are almost gone.

Name: pinaskongmahal
City/State/Country: usa
IP Address: 199.96.203.220

Comments

sbejar: It's better to herd off the signatories of the 'Go Home Yankees' when they abrogated the treaty for US to station their 7th Fleet and 13th Air Force in the Phil and let them drive away the Intsek in Spratleys. Signatories were:Pitong Aquino, Laurel, Maceda, Pimentel, Saguisag, Salonga, Tanada, Enrile, Estrada and Guingona. Let them fight at Spratly if they're still alive. When the US forces were in the Phil, we were untouchable. Now that we're the poorest begging for alms in Asia, even the tiny islet of Taiwan bigger than Bohol, is claiming Spratlys as theirs.

Name: jjj
City/State/Country: fayetteville n.c. us
IP Address: 166.137.9.98

Comments

Pretty soon if someone needs to swim in Manila, BORA, LA UNION, PALAWAN beaches--- Pinoys will need a A CHINESE VISA. Those idiots in MANILA are really sucks, they might have a Chinese blood in them for allowing the AMERICAN bases to close, now they a begging from them for help. IT IS more FUN in PHILIPPINES ---number 4 in the world for being a crook country. Those pabaon really tells as a result of no fighter planes, gun boats, surface to air missiles, etc. Pacquiao cannot do it alone to man the Chinese invasion. USA SHOULD TAKE back THOSE BASES IN EXCHANGE FOR AMERICAN HELP.

Name: nbj
City/State/Country: dalla tx
IP Address: 166.137.9.98

Comments

The CHINESE can do better running the Philippine government as compared to those crooks in Philippines. Those crooks will be 6 feet below in one day after conviction, they are the only one who can clean those crooks not those kangaroos in SC, palace, Sandigan officers etc. The Chinese have the solution to the Pinas diarrhea--- firing squad. I bet anyone in Ph that those general have sold those mothballed fighter planes and boats to the junk yard man. Please have their SALN check as well

Name: CRM
City/State/Country: SAN DIEGO,CA
IP Address: 159.71.254.248

Comments

No matter what we cannot win any war if the Americans will not support the Philippines because we are very broke, corrupted and no more money to buy new equipment to defend the country. So before it is too late, wake up Filipino people especially those who are demonstrating against the Americans. You cannot do it alone

Name: bongj
City/State/Country: high level, alberta
IP Address: 50.93.6.216

Comments

Send the senators who voted for the removal of Subic Naval Base and Clark Air Base to the Spratlys . Ngayon tahimik silang lahat.

Name: Steve R
City/State/Country: California
IP Address: 98.234.19.64

Comments

Vanessa Lee, Likewise, I believe the authorities should return the defunct US Base. What is happening at Panatag Shoal could be an indication of China’s trial & error plan to test the PH’s resolve in protecting its territory before they’ll make their final attempt to take the PH in their fold. PH was attacked & governed by Spain, the United States & Japan. Japan was driven away by the Americans who taught us Democracy before they gave the PH independence in July 4, 1946. To date mostly corrupt officials governed PH & China maybe thinking that the PH is ripe for the ‘taking’, time for them to take over the PH. The return of defunct U S Bases to PH COULD reduce PRC’s perceive plan to Zero.

Name: HMS
City/State/Country: New York NY
IP Address: 67.241.96.149

Comments

Schools of thought: 1) America will not get into a fight with any country, much less China over the Philippines; 2)The short sighted Senators that voted to shut down the US Bases should now be made to account for their decision; 3) This may be a blessing in disguise for it might serve to solve the problems of the pinoys with their crooked and corrupt officials; 4) This is just the start of the partitioning of the Philippines. It's just a matter of time before other asian countries start their own intrusions and claims seeing how helpless and friendless the Philippines is; 5) Just wait and see, the Crooks will use this incident to distract the Pinoys. Pretty soon Corona, Arroyo, etc. will be a distant memory. Thank God for China, they will say.

Name: Tomastabak
City/State/Country: Ylaya
IP Address: 71.198.97.240

Comments

Yes, we could stand up to China. The way we do it, is exporting our politicians (PNOY included) over there, have them do what they do best which is the practice of graft and corruption in government. That would definitely set China back into the Stone Age.

Name: AHKO
City/State/Country: Brunei
IP Address: 121.54.13.37

Comments

China only needs to piss and Philippines will drown, that is the sad reality, what we need is to invite the US into the country to counter China's aggression.

Name: JRH
City/State/Country: Montreal, Canada
IP Address: 70.82.114.98

Comments

Today, it's a war or words between the Phils & China. In the event that an accident or a small-scale confrontation happens between us & the Mandarins we will lose...guaranteed. The equation is that great. It's like an elephant versus the ant. Asia's Goliath (China) against a weak nation (Philippines). We can't protect our territory. Anybody who says otherwise is dreaming & out of reality.

Name: E. Tan
City/State/Country: Ongpin, Manila China
IP Address: 70.160.144.157

Comments

Philippines should never ever think of going to war with China, one reason among many is, Filipinos will be better off having the Chinese run the business of the country than the Filipino politicians whose main priority is to enrich themselves and nothing else. They should be all shot once the Chinese take over the Malacañang.

Name: Lydia Mandanas
City/State/Country: U.S.
IP Address: 71.138.134.238

Comments

The growing tensions between China and the Philippines is a wake up call for all Filipinos to unite. I strongly agree with Senate Pres. Ponce Enrile that Filipinos must have unity. In times like this, we must show to the world that we are one nation, one people and we are together and united in our efforts to support our rights and sovereignty. Forget dirty politics which consumed our nation and the root cause why we are economically and militarily weak. Our strength must come first from the inside so it will project outside. God bless the Philippines and the Filipino people. MABUHAY ANG PILIPINAS!!!

Name: Jing
City/State/Country: Cavite
IP Address: 193.188.60.123

Comments

- JUST DONT GIVE UP THE CLAIM TAPOS!!! At pag ukulan nalang kung papano mababawsan ng malaki ang KURAPSYON!! Dahil wala rin namang magagawa kahit pa mga Kano kung sukupin pa ng China ngayon ang lahat ng area na pinagtatalunan... Mag uusap lang ang mga yan (KANO at CHINO) kung papano sila makikinabang... na magmamalasakit ang Amerika sa Pinas? Dios kopo... MALABO!

Name: GFJBHEDF
City/State/Country: Hercules
IP Address: 67.188.19.40

Comments

VFA Balikatan west of Palawan is a statement to the bully. Sooner or later King Kong will have to back off. Its got to much to lose. Primarily, the $billions US owes Beijing. 2nd, US is Mr. Wong's biggest economic trading partner. 3rd, Panda Bear is all about business, not war, specially against a powerful opponent, such as US. Under these realities, Egg Foo Yong has really no alternative.., except to say sai jian already.

Name: Gene
City/State/Country: Ontario, Canada
IP Address: 174.93.113.120

Comments

On May 11, Filipinos all over the world will hold rallies in front of embassies of Communist Red China. To Fil-Cans, OFWs here in Canada, let us support the country and show to the world our unity in denouncing the threat and bullying of Communist Red China. I know you would be enthusiastic and patriotic to fight for a moral cause in defense of the country. Posters let us meet in Toronto before China's embassy or maybe in Ottawa. Our differences in expressing our views must not be a hindrance to this very important event. Long live the Philippines. Though I'm a Canadian citizen, I still love my country of birth.

Name: Celso (Shell) Madarang
City/State/Country: Clovis, California
IP Address: 75.31.167.108

Comments

I have only one message to all eligible voters in the Philippines. " Be wise, intelligent and be very careful next time you vote for any government official."

Name: John B.
City/State/Country: Sherman Oaks. Ca,US
IP Address: 76.216.152.14

Comments

It has always been a good rallying point to "defend" our native shores. But with an inadequate and inept armed forces, what we have is realistically a token army, incapable to repel 'enemies', specially a superpower like China. Tragically, much of the same can be said of the sorry state of our government, operating with a lot of posturing, and false perception, but without real SUBSTANCE and purpose. It's a truly a sad reality, but our nation, just like any other, is only as great as the leaders we install.

Name: HMS
City/State/Country: New York NY
IP Address: 67.241.96.149

Comments

China invaded and occupied Tibet which is represented by a symbol of peace and goodness - the Dalai Lama. And the UN would not/could not do anything. Now China is claiming part of the Philippines represented by crooks, thieves, scam artists, demented politicians and all kinds of dysfunctional people, and the UN will do something? If it does it would be for CHINA'S benefit! End of conversation.

Name: JRH
City/State/Country: Montreal, Canada
IP Address: 70.82.114.98

Comments

The New York Times Sunday Review Opinion Section said 'In the Phils, haunted by history' as the title..followed by 'America's policies & its defense ties with Manila, have always benefitted the Filipino elite'. These statements are double-edged. After the Phils refused to renew the leases of Subic & Clark Air Force Base there was no other alternative but for them to leave. It seems that this 1986 decision was bitterly remembered by the Americans as a dark spot in our relationship with them. So, now that we're in dire need of modernizing our forces, we have to go to Washington & beg for left-over aircraft, vintage destroyers, obsolete vehicles, etc. to boost up our military. What a way to go. PMA graduates. No way.

Name: GFJBHEDF
City/State/Country: Hercules
IP Address: 67.188.19.40

Comments

The strength of China's military is no secret. Millions army - Air Force - Navy. Its movements, Air/sea, is monitored 24/7 > Satellite - Nuclear subs - U2 - Drones - Internal agents. Today's technology, (in all facet), is so much better than even 5 years ago. For all its economic wealth/power, China is continually under the microscope, despite its protests. Its economic influence universal is enormous. It cannot afford to jeopardize its enormous universal assets for Scarborough shoal, if only it can find a way to get out of the situation unscathed.., sooner or later.., One of my favorite food is a bowl of Peking duck, (half/chopped), over bok choy, over brown rice, using chopsticks.

Name: Todo
City/State/Country: Lanao del Norte
IP Address: 121.54.47.67

Comments

I doubt if the US will come to the aid of the RP in case of a shooting war with China. Take note that the Scarborough shoal was not mentioned as part of the territory of RP in the 1951 MDT. Besides, why would the US help a country that booted it out in 1991? We claimed to be sovereign and detested the presence of the US here, why now ask them to help us? Maulaw ta ana oi.

Name: jessie
City/State/Country: honolulu
IP Address: 24.165.32.113

Comments

I want diplomatic agreement succeed. According to international agreement, the 200 nautical miles to the nearest country is covered by that country. It means the Scarborough Shoal is covered or with-in the limit of a country closest to that country. The analysis is as simple as that and no other explanation.

Name: JRH
City/State/Country: Montreal, Canada
IP Address: 70.82.114.98

Comments

The Scarborough shoal or Panatag shoal, as the Filipinos call these islets or Huangyan Islands as the Chinese claim & according to them have been an integral part of China for 8 centuries. If that is true & it's the case, then they should claim them in the International Court that they are the real owner of this God-damn piece of trouble. China even had the audacity to report that the U.S. acts from narrow self-interest & promotes the 'China threat' in pursuit of hegemony (domination or leadership) & economic advantage. What a paradox. It's China who hectors everybody else in Asia.

Name: Lydia Mandanas
City/State/Country: U.S.
IP Address: 67.116.239.18

Comments

Chinese's display of arrogance with their speeding ship allegedly veered dangerously close and posing danger to Philippine vessels may actually be a bait. This was an attempt to provoke the Philippines to fire the first shot, so they can retaliate and say, they (China ) act in self defense. The map of the Philippines dating back to the Spanish era shows Spratly belongs to the Philippines. Now they would like to do some development projects in the area. This will only serve to increase the tensions. I hope our allies are ready and united with us in war and in peace and prevent China from further acts of intrusions. With God's blessing, KAYA NATIN TO. God said "Do not be afraid". Let us not act on impulse; keep our heads cool. VICTORY IS OURS!!!

Name: jfr
City/State/Country: carolina
IP Address: 166.137.8.244

Comments

With the Chinese running the Pinas government, it would eliminate the corruption that plaque the Pinas for generations. PHILIPPINES is totally infested with corrupt people from the lowest barangay up yo the highest level specially to those carrying BRASS. Some barangay heads are now erecting mansion, bought some properties, businesses, and driving sport cars like BMW, MERCEDES, SUV, and controls lots businesses, while their constituents are surviving on $ 1 a day budget. Philippines government or the dirty dozen must be ashamed now to ask for help FROM US tax payer for forcing out the AMERICANS from the their bases.

Name: Vanessa Lee
City/State/Country: Kuwait
IP Address: 37.36.197.45

Comments

This is high time magbago na kayo mga corrupt public servants maging honest at mag rely na lamang kayo sa inyong mga sueldo wag na ninyo pakialaman ang kaban ng bayan maawa at makonsiyensiya naman kayo till now walang progreso ang ating bansa dahilan sa inyo na iniisip ay pansariling interest magpayaman lamang at i satisfy and walang katapusang pagnanasa sa yaman at kapangyarihan. Maawa na kayo sa ating bansa at isipin na hangat me magnanakaw na katulad ninyo hinding hindi tataas ang katayuan na ating bansa sa larangan ng kabuhayan, depensa at iba pa. Samahan natin at magkaisa sa prinsipyo ng ating Pres. Noy patungo sa paglilinis ng masamang elemento na katulad nito. Maraming salamat Pres. Noy God bless your agenda of reform.

Name: Mel
City/State/Country: Virginia, USA
IP Address: 164.167.34.67

Comments

Weak and Defenseless Philippines. Blame it to our citizens. Philippines will not be in this predicament if those crooked politicians were not voted in office, which in turn, appointed another batches of crooks into the gov't position with same intention of lining their pockets. These crooks should be exiled to a remote island or better yet be shot for treason.

Name: Jorge Villanueva
City/State/Country: Canada
IP Address: 142.162.137.168

Comments

We are isolating the problem one by one. Had it not been for the millions taken away from the government coffers there would have been enough left for the Phil. Armed Forces. Had it not been for the incessant stealing or outright graft and corruption by government officials the country would not be deep in debt. The people should demand action against this group and should follow closely the Corona impeachment. Its success and failure is important for this anti-corruption drive.

Name: GFJBHEDF
City/State/Country: Hercules
IP Address: 67.188.19.40

Comments

What's the wanton soup idea of 14th Chinese vessels insolent occupation of Philippine's UNCLOS/EEZ Scarborough (Panatag) shoal? To show the world that they are powerful? That the Philippines is powerless to defend its own shores? The answer to both is yes. China is also sending a testament of how It governs China's people.., by force.., by overwhelming force.., by brutal force when needed.

Name: blumentritt
City/State/Country: njus
IP Address: 68.197.155.123

Comments

No way China can corrupt Pnoy administrations, gone are their days of corrupting the dwarf Lady and the broker Leprechaun Devenesian blindman who almost succeeded in giving concessions and selling most of the reefs along with Spratlys. In the event those Chingchang battleships will fire the first shot - condemnation against China will be worldwide  by the Filipinos and by the international communities  as well.

Name: EdP
City/State/Country: San Diego, CA.
IP Address: 68.6.130.250

Comments

Just about all comments have serious concerns about the prevailing apathy that have saturated the political arena since the Philippines became independent. Complacency mentioned by some became the norm because the people in general did not expect such intrusion by China knowing that there is a great ocean body separating the two countries. We'll this proves that reality to the Pilipino people is knocking at the front door.

Name: JRH
City/State/Country: Montreal, Canada
IP Address: 70.82.114.98

Comments

GMA News: "U.S. triples 2012 Phil military aid to $30 million (U.S.). What a bloody joke. That's about 2 F-16 jet fighters in today's market. With this, our poor gov't should then rejoice in this pathetic statement from them. Pres. Aquino should immediately recall our 2 defense ministers who are negotiating for scrap military hardware & obsolete armories from the U.S. govt. I wish we forget this nonsense now. The fact is the U.S. is really playing footsies with the Chinese. Should a real confrontation occur, the U.S. would only observe & give nonsense advise in this situation. I am giving my middle finger to them.

Name: Steve R
City/State/Country: California
IP Address: 98.234.19.64

Comments

With an outright disrespect by China for increasing their vessels at Panatag Shoal & continued illegal fishing, the Senator Judges are faced with their task to end the trial by end of May as recommended by the Presiding Judge, JP Enrile. There is no 2 way about it. The Senator’s backs are up-against the wall as the 2013 election is near & voters will likely weight-in with votes if the trial will distract their Senators ability to help secure a positive outcome of the Panatag Shoal dispute. Senators voted out Subic & Clark out of the PH & as a result, PRC has taken steps to boldly claim Zambales, PH. The ball called ‘nationalism’ is in the Senator’s side of the court. Redemption time, win it for all Filipinos.

Name: WDC
City/State/Country: California
IP Address: 63.193.188.76

Comments

I bet when the bullets start flying between Philippines and China, those corrupt politicians in the Philippines will be the first to leave the country. Now folks, next elections if you vote these cowards again, you will be speaking Chinese!

Name: A. Poli
City/State/Country: Anywhere
IP Address: 184.148.76.60

Comments

I see this as a failure of diplomacy. Think about.

Name: JRH
City/State/Country: Montreal, Canada
IP Address: 70.82.114.98

Comments

Phil. Star reported that the Phil needs 48 fighter jets, 6 mini-submarines, etc. costing approx $1Billion during Pres Aquino's 6-yr term. This modernization is long overdue & a tad late. It sounds good on paper or boastful speeches but doesn't hold much water. The truth is our gov't gravely neglected the military update & constant upgrade of military hardware. Corrupt AFP officials systematically stole the funding thru corrupt practices of pasalubong & pabaon or whatever perks you can think of. Even if we acquire them now, we still have to train the pilots, crew, personnel on how to handle this sophisticated planes & the naval officers & crew how to man a warship or a submarine or operate hardware & other technical qualifications that go with them.

Name: Lydia Mandanas
City/State/Country: U.S.
IP Address: 67.121.125.152

Comments

Aside from the U.S. we have also a defense treaty with Australia and ASEAN. What have we done to assure that they will be side by side with us against China? With 30 Chinese vessels facing only 2 ships of the Philippines, do Sec. del Rosario and Sec. Gazmin still feel very comfortable about the standoff? Why not gather all resources available? We know about our 2+2 with U.S, how about Australia and the ASEAN? Have we contacted them? Remember, "Daig ng maagap ang masipag". In our moments of silence, let us also pray, and pray hard, that we survive the crisis, AMEN.

Name: JASON GARCA
City/State/Country: SEATTLE , WA
IP Address: 67.170.12.60

Comments

"People Power" on boats, see if the Chinese can stop them all, even with their high-powered guns. If the Chinese shoot them, they will be condemned by the world.

Name: A. Poli
City/State/Country: Anywhere
IP Address: 184.148.76.60

Comments

Look, at the moment there are now many OFWs working in China. The trade between the two country is growing as well. Our neighbors like Hong Kong, Taiwan, Singapore, even Malaysia are ethic Chinese dominated as well. Those guys look at Filipinos as lowly labour and house help. The businesses in Phil's are all controlled by the Chinese.

Name: Manuel C. Diaz
City/State/Country: Antipolo City
IP Address: 180.191.199.211

Comments

Instead of this 48 jets 6 mini-submarines etc. etc. Philippines will just be wasting the money to buy all these equipment. These equipment will just end in the scrap yard. Better talk to the Chinese it will cost the Philippines less. It will not escalate the arms race and speaking of arms race China manufactures its own arsenals while the Philippines have no industrial base to maintain these expensive equipment. Let the Pinoys stop dreaming and wake up Philippines cannot match China's military power.

Name: Good Conscience
City/State/Country: USA
IP Address: 98.198.245.232

Comments

The Philippine government had been run so far by officials who really did not think beyond tomorrow. No planning and no foresight. The only planning these people make is how to enrich themselves. What a shame. With all the remittances coming from OFWs which amounts to billions of dollars, pouring into the country, this nation and country should be one of the most prosperous nations in the world. Other countries export material items. Sad to say, the Philippines export human beings and causing separation of family members. The Filipino people follow - the leaders lead. We need good leaders. We need honest government officials who are public servants. Not public thieves. It is really that simple.

Name: LPiF
City/State/Country: Sa Loob, Mandaluyong
IP Address: 64.40.183.70

Comments

"We must have a strong navy and air force in order to defend our archipelago."- First things first-- we have to have a strong and well fed citizenry to make it worthwhile to defend our archipelago.

Name: As I See It
City/State/Country: Cebu City/SD,CA
IP Address: 68.7.248.64

Comments

ESTRADA last year celebrated with other senators the 20th anniversary of the rejection of US mil bases in the Philippines (Sept 16, 1991) and said with pride, "our finest hour." While former senator VICTOR ZIGA told, "one of my proudest moments." ENRILE said he voted against US bases "for national sovereignty." I wonder if these great pretenders & TRAPOS would use the same nice rhetoric and sweet speeches if they are asked 'How are we going the defend our territorial integrity & nat'l sovereignty against foreign incursions if and when US Congress decides to end mutual defense treaty with our country?

Name: Kimberly Z
City/State/Country: CA
IP Address: 72.87.197.224

Comments

"The fact that Scarborough (Panatag to Filipinos) Shoal is on the country’s continental shelf just 124 nautical miles from Zambales—well within its 200-mile exclusive economic zone—has not stopped the Chinese from claiming it as their own." lol found these so-called "facts" interesting, just because it's close to Phil so it should be clammed by Phil? How about Alaska or Guam~how about U.K.'s Channel Islands...

Name: Duncan Alexander McKenzie
City/State/Country: Philippines
IP Address: 203.177.66.250

Comments

The USA is in economic and military decline. China is in its ascendancy as an economic and military superpower. The Philippines failed to industrialize and to properly use its resources, both human and material, to position itself as a military power with a credible deterrent force. The precise reasons for this are outlined in my book 'The Unlucky Country' available on Amazon. China is now engaged in the end game of its incredible economic and military expansion. It is now testing the resolve of the USA and nations like the Philippines. China will re-write the geographical boundaries to their advantage. As Churchill once said In the area of international relations there are no friends or enemies. There are only interests. My book tells why the Philippines remains in a position of weakness.

Name: a US Vet
City/State/Country: Tagbilaran, Philippines
IP Address: 112.198.64.51

Comments

Finally someone pens an article that goes to the heart of the problem. Because of the greed of public and military officials and the total complacency of the Philippine people the Philippines it totally unable to defend it's people and its territory. Graft and greed by most politicians in all levels of government are to blame and the Philippine people allow this. This is what happens when you sell your vote, and your country away, for p1,000.

Name: Jun Sapote
City/State/Country: Angeles City
IP Address: 124.197.32.158

Comments

I would like to remind the Chinese government that, we the Filipinos are not fools! if you think you can bully us?! you are dead wrong! If you want to mess up our country go ahead...make our day!!! We fought the Spaniards, the Americans, the Japanese... you might as well be next!!!

Name: Manny Lim
City/State/Country: Philippines
IP Address: 180.194.251.29

Comments

At this TIME we are NO match to China's military might. SURELY the Americans are not going to help. So better to play diplomacy. However, when we are strong again then we fight/take back the islands if they still insist. For now we will easily be wiped out. Phil-Chinese (Chinoys) wake up. Show your gratitude when our parents were accepted by this country in time of distress. Lets support the PHILIPPINES our country.